Without the super stars, Guardiola is just an ordinary coach. Barcelona had Messi, Manchester City has De Bruyne, Bayern has no Champions League.

In the Champions League quarter-finals, the Premier League's two blues turned into "two failures", Chelsea was eliminated by Paris Saint-Germain, and Manchester City was eliminated by a depleted Real Madrid. Guardiola, coaching the wealthy Manchester City for ten years, has only one Champions League title. Guardiola is the true leader at Manchester City, able to buy whoever he wants, with club funds fully available, purchasing star players every year. However, Manchester City's only one Champions League trophy in ten years is actively unsatisfactory. Especially in the last two seasons, Manchester City has been eliminated by Real Madrid both years, last year stopping in the quarter-finals, this year stopping in the quarter-finals.

So the question arises,Why is Manchester City a favorite in the Champions League every year but always eliminated early?Actually, the reason is simple, that is Guardiola is overrated,Guardiola without the assistance of super stars is just an ordinary coach!

The Champions League is the highest-level competition for clubs. Guardiola has only coached three teams in his career, all top clubs: Barcelona, Bayern, and Manchester City. Guardiola has won three Champions League titles in his coaching career,two with Barcelona (2008-09 season, 2010-11 season), zero with Bayern, one with Manchester City (2022-23 season). Guardiola achieved trebles during his coaching periods at Barcelona and Manchester City. Guardiola's coaching honors are quite good, but this is achieved by coaching top teams all along, and also Guardiola winning Champions League titles always had the assistance of super stars.

During Guardiola's time at Barcelona, it's不用说, with Messi such a football king, the strongest player in football history assisting, winning two Champions League titles is理所当然. Guardiola coaching Manchester City for ten years only won one Champions League title, this still with De Bruyne such the Premier League's top midfielder assisting. Besides De Bruyne, winter's Mahrez was the glove king. With these super players, Guardiola led Manchester City to win one Champions League title. After De Bruyne, Mahrez and other good players left, now Manchester City has become extremely rough,根本无法 play passing-control football. Now Manchester City plays pseudo-passing-control, back-passing and sideways passing占据 most possession time, without creativity to create killing chances. Without De Bruyne's precise passing, Haaland is just a very ordinary tall forward who cannot head or play back-to-goal counter-attack striker.

Guardiola winning league titles都是凭借 super阵容以及每一个转会窗口 stacking players的方式夺得,比如今年 winter window Manchester City signed Semenyo and Guehi, recruitment力度很大,但 Manchester City this season Premier League title race彻底掉队,落后 Arsenal多达9分, Champions League被 Real Madrid双杀止步 quarter-finals! Manchester City年年 Champions League踢 Real Madrid, Guardiola至今还没有研究出对付 Real Madrid的战术,只能说 Guardiola业务能力不强!

Summary:Without the assistance of super stars, Guardiola = ordinary coach!Do you agree with this viewpoint?